How USS Mingo Became the First Submarine of Japan’s Postwar Navy | Patrol Reports

Photo courtesy of Japanese Maritime Self-Defense Force via Jane's Fighting Ships, 1956-57 courtesy of Robert Hurst.

USS Mingo (SS-261) spent much of her life doing what submarines are built to do: disappear. She slipped beneath the Pacific during the Second World War, hunted Japanese shipping, rescued stranded airmen, survived storms, and eventually faded into the reserve fleet. By all rights, that should have been the end of her story.

Instead, the most unusual chapter came after the shooting stopped.

When people think about the alliance between the United States and Japan, they usually picture diplomats signing treaties, politicians standing before flags, or perhaps photographs of Cold War summits. Very few think about an aging submarine. Yet Mingo helped build that relationship in a way no diplomat ever could. Before she was finished, she would sail under both flags.

The boat began life at the Electric Boat yard in Groton, Connecticut. Her keel was laid on March 21, 1942, at a time when American shipyards were producing warships with astonishing speed. Every slipway seemed occupied. Every launch carried fresh urgency. Mingo entered the water on November 30 and was commissioned on February 12, 1943, under Lieutenant Commander Ralph C. Lynch Jr.

She was a standard Gato-class submarine on paper, although there is a lesson in trusting paper too much. Mingo carried ten torpedo tubes, a deck gun, and enough range to cross vast stretches of ocean without support. Unfortunately, she also carried H.O.R. diesel engines.

Submariners have never been shy about expressing opinions regarding machinery that threatens to leave them stranded hundreds of miles from home. The Hooven-Owens-Rentschler engines developed a reputation throughout the fleet that bordered on legendary. One veteran later joked that the only thing more dangerous than Japanese destroyers was unreliable engineering. Like most sea stories, the line was probably exaggerated. Like most sea stories, there was probably truth hiding inside it.

The Navy eventually replaced Mingo’s troublesome engines with Fairbanks-Morse opposed-piston diesels during a major overhaul. Histories tend to mention that fact in a sentence and move on. The crew almost certainly did not. Reliable machinery is not exciting reading, but ask any submariner which he would rather have, a heroic newspaper headline or engines that actually start.

Mingo sailed west in the summer of 1943 and entered a submarine war that was still finding its footing. The popular image today is one of unstoppable American submarines strangling Japanese commerce. The reality was considerably messier. Torpedoes malfunctioned. Intelligence failed. Captains chased contacts that vanished into weather or darkness. Some patrols produced little more than frustration and paperwork.

Her first patrol took her into waters around the Palau Islands. She attacked merchant shipping when opportunities appeared and even surfaced to bombard Japanese facilities on Sorol Island. There is something almost old-fashioned about a submarine firing her deck gun at a shore target. It sounds more like a scene from the age of sail than the age of radar.

The second patrol ranged across the Marshalls, Carolines, and Marianas. Mingo launched torpedoes at what was believed to be a Japanese carrier and reported hits. Wartime submarine reports are fascinating documents because certainty is often impossible. A captain glimpses explosions, dives to avoid depth charges, and writes his report based on what he believes he saw. Historians arrive decades later and try to sort it all out.

Following overhaul, Mingo returned to sea. Her third patrol in the South China Sea produced little offensive success, although intelligence gathering occupied much of her effort. Such patrols rarely receive much attention. Then again, reconnaissance seldom earns glory. It simply wins wars quietly.

The fourth patrol finally produced a confirmed victory when Mingo sank the destroyer Tamanami off Luzon on July 7, 1944. Destroyers were not helpless merchantmen. They existed for the specific purpose of finding and killing submarines. Every submariner understood that attacking one meant accepting substantial risk.

Then the boat’s mission changed.

By late 1944, Mingo found herself assigned lifeguard duty around Borneo and the Celebes. The term sounds almost comforting until one remembers what it meant. American bombers were operating deep over enemy territory. When crews went down, somebody had to retrieve them before the Japanese did.

Sixteen B-24 airmen found safety aboard Mingo during that patrol. One cannot help wondering what those men saw when the submarine appeared. Relief certainly. Gratitude perhaps. Maybe simple disbelief. A black hull emerging from the sea must have looked less like a warship and more like a miracle.

The patrol offered another reminder that war rarely conforms to expectations. Mingo sank coastal freighters with her deck gun, then survived an accidental attack by an American Liberator bomber. Somewhere there is probably a file folder documenting the incident in neat bureaucratic language. One suspects the conversations aboard Mingo were considerably less polite.

Her most successful offensive patrol came that Christmas. On December 25, 1944, Mingo used radar to conduct a nighttime attack west of Borneo, sinking the tanker Manila Maru.

It is tempting to view such sinkings as isolated victories. They were not. By late 1944, Japanese logistics were collapsing. Every tanker destroyed represented fuel that would never reach aircraft, factories, or warships. The Japanese empire was not merely losing ships. It was losing the ability to move.

Mingo’s final patrol brought a different enemy altogether. On February 10, 1945, she encountered a massive typhoon. The storm inflicted severe structural damage and swept two crewmen overboard. Naval histories sometimes reduce such losses to a sentence. A line in a report. A notation in a casualty list. Two sailors vanished into the sea during a storm and never came home. The war continued. The patrol continued. Families received telegrams. History moved forward because history always moves forward.

When peace arrived, Mingo returned to the United States and entered the reserve fleet. Had she remained there, she would have been remembered as a respectable combat veteran with five battle stars and a handful of notable patrols. That alone would have justified her place in submarine history.

Instead, history took a turn that would have sounded absurd to her wartime crew.

Imagine walking into Mingo’s crew’s mess in 1944 and announcing that within a decade the submarine would belong to Japan. The reaction would probably have involved laughter, disbelief, and perhaps a few colorful observations regarding your sanity.

Yet that is precisely what happened.

In 1955, under the Mutual Defense Assistance Program, the United States transferred Mingo to Japan. Renamed JDS Kuroshio (SS-501), she became the first submarine of the postwar Japan Maritime Self-Defense Force.

The Day, New London, CT, June 21, 1955

That fact alone deserves a moment’s pause.

Some of the Japanese sailors who stepped aboard Kuroshio had lived through the war. Some undoubtedly remembered American submarines from the opposite side of the conflict. Now they were learning their trade aboard one.

History rarely offers cleaner examples of how thoroughly circumstances can change.

For more than a decade, Kuroshio served as a training platform and anti-submarine warfare target. Japanese submariners learned procedures, tactics, maintenance practices, and operational habits aboard a boat built during the greatest naval war in history. The lessons extended far beyond a single submarine. They influenced the development of Japan’s future submarine force and helped establish traditions that continue today.

Ships teach. Sailors teach. Institutions teach. Long after steel begins to age, experience continues traveling from one generation to the next.

Kuroshio’s service ended in 1966. She was returned to American control, later struck from the Naval Register, sold back to Japan, and eventually sunk as a target in 1973.

There is a certain poetry in that ending. The submarine spent her life serving two nations, survived a world war, outlived her original purpose, and helped build something entirely new. Not many warships can make that claim.

USS Mingo earned five battle stars during World War II. She hunted ships, rescued airmen, endured machinery troubles, weathered storms, and carried her crews through years of uncertainty. Those accomplishments matter.

What makes her memorable, though, is the chapter that came afterward. The submarine that once carried war across the Pacific eventually helped train the sailors of a former enemy. Diplomats signed the agreements and politicians made the speeches, but down at the practical level where sailors learn their trade, Mingo became part of the foundation of a new relationship.

That is not the sort of legacy anybody could have predicted in 1943. Which, come to think of it, is one reason history remains worth studying. It keeps refusing to follow the script.

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑