On March 25, 1915, the submarine USS F-4 slipped beneath the waters off Honolulu, Hawaii, for what was supposed to be a routine training dive. She never came back. When she failed to surface, anxiety quickly turned to dread. The Navy had lost its first submarine at sea with all hands aboard. The disaster was not only a human tragedy, it was also a crisis for a service that was still experimenting with the strange new world of undersea warfare. Submarines were only beginning to find their place in naval strategy, and to lose one so suddenly and completely raised difficult questions about their safety, their reliability, and their future.
The F-4 lay in over 300 feet of water, at a depth far beyond anything divers had ever attempted. At that time, the limits of diving were uncertain, and the technology to work at such depths was crude and dangerous. For many observers, the loss seemed final. The men were gone, and the submarine might as well have been buried on the bottom of the sea. But the U.S. Navy refused to accept that answer. Over the course of four months, in the face of incredible challenges, they would attempt something no one had ever done before: raise a sunken submarine from the deep.
The F-4 was one of America’s early submarines, part of the “F class” designed by John Holland’s Electric Boat Company. Commissioned in 1912, she displaced just 330 tons, carried a crew of 21 men, and measured 142 feet in length. By modern standards she was small, cramped, and primitive, but she represented the cutting edge of American naval innovation at the time.
On that March morning, the submarine put to sea for a dive with her crew of officers and enlisted men. Submarine operations in those days were still as much art as science, and safety margins were thin. Something went catastrophically wrong. Later investigations suggested that corroded hull plating failed under pressure, flooding the forward battery compartment. Poisonous chlorine gas would have filled the air as seawater reacted with the acid batteries. The men had little chance to survive, and the submarine sank quickly to the bottom.
The Navy launched immediate searches but could do little beyond confirming her resting place. The loss was not only a blow to the families of the 21 men, but also to the reputation of the Navy’s experimental submarine force. The press seized on the story, highlighting both the danger and the mystery of submarines. For the Navy, the sinking represented a challenge: they had to recover the boat, both for the sake of the dead and for the future of undersea warfare.
Raising the F-4 was not simply a matter of pulling on a chain and hauling her up. The submarine weighed over 300 tons and lay at a depth of more than 300 feet. At that depth, the water pressure is crushing, and no diver had ever worked so far down. Divers at the time relied on heavy canvas suits, lead-soled boots, and surface-supplied air pumped down through rubber hoses. A mistake, a burst hose, or a tangled line could kill a man instantly. Yet without divers, there was no way to attach cables to the wreck.
The Navy turned to innovation. Lieutenant Commander Julius A. Furer, a naval constructor, was put in charge of the engineering challenge. He was joined by Rear Admiral C. B. T. Moore and Lieutenant Charles Smith, who brought both leadership and technical skill. Together they designed a system using specially built steel pontoons that could be filled with air to provide lift. The idea was simple in theory: attach the pontoons to the submarine, blow them full of air, and let buoyancy bring the wreck to the surface. In practice, it was anything but simple.
First, divers had to reach the wreck and work around it, often in darkness and zero visibility. They had to dig cables into the mud beneath the hull and secure them so that the lift would be even. Each dive was a gamble, and several divers came close to death in the process. The pressure at 300 feet could crush the air supply hoses flat, cutting off a diver’s lifeline. The Navy modified pumps, reinforced hoses, and learned through trial and error how to push the limits of diving technology.
Week after week, the men worked, attaching cables, adjusting pontoons, and preparing for the great lift. The press followed the story closely, and public attention mounted as each new report came out of Honolulu. Many doubted it could be done.
Finally, on August 29, 1915, the Navy was ready. Everything was in place, the pontoons secured, the cables tightened. On that Sunday, the order was given. Pumps roared, air rushed into the pontoons, and slowly, against the pull of the deep, the F-4 began to rise.
It was a moment of high tension. If a cable snapped, if a pontoon failed, the submarine could sink again, perhaps beyond recovery. But inch by inch she came upward, until at last, after more than four months on the bottom, the dark shape of the submarine broke the surface. The feat was unprecedented. No one had ever raised a submarine from such depths before. The men on the recovery team had achieved something that would shape naval salvage for decades to come.
When the boat was secured and towed into Honolulu Harbor, it was not a scene of celebration. Instead, it was solemn. Inside the hull were the remains of the 21 men who had been trapped since March. The Navy handled the recovery of their bodies with reverence, acknowledging their sacrifice as pioneers of the submarine service. For their families, there was at least the small comfort of knowing their loved ones had not been abandoned to the sea.
The raising of the F-4 was more than an act of respect for the dead. It was also an invaluable opportunity to study what had gone wrong. Naval engineers examined the corroded hull and confirmed that weakened plating near the battery compartment had given way. It was a design flaw that would have to be corrected if submarines were to become a reliable weapon of war. The tragedy thus spurred improvements in hull design, corrosion protection, and maintenance.
Just as important were the lessons learned in salvage and deep diving. The techniques developed in 1915 formed the foundation of modern submarine rescue operations. The Navy now knew that a sunken submarine could, in fact, be raised, and that divers could work at depths previously thought impossible. The courage of the men who descended to the wreck pushed forward the limits of diving technology, paving the way for future advances.
In a larger sense, the raising of the F-4 sent a message about the Navy’s values. Submariners could take confidence in the knowledge that if the worst happened, the Navy would not leave them behind. The Silent Service, as it would later be called, was built not only on technology but on trust. The salvage of the F-4 helped cement that bond.
The story of the F-4 is ultimately not just about engineering or innovation. It is about the men who served aboard her and the price they paid. They entered a dangerous new world of undersea warfare when submarines were unproven and the risks were poorly understood. Their loss was the first great tragedy of the American submarine force, and their recovery was the first great triumph.
Today, the F-4 rests in a permanent grave at Pearl Harbor. She is rarely visited, and her story is little known outside the circles of naval history. Yet she remains a symbol of sacrifice and perseverance. The men who perished aboard her and the men who risked their lives to raise her together wrote a chapter of history that should never be forgotten.
On August 29, 1915, the United States Navy did what no one thought possible. It raised a sunken submarine from 300 feet of water and brought her crew home. The recovery of the USS F-4 was born out of tragedy, but it became a landmark in naval engineering and a testament to the determination of sailors and divers who refused to yield to the sea. The echoes of that day still resonate in every modern submarine rescue system, in every dive that pushes the limits of depth, and in the enduring commitment of the Navy to its own.
The story of the F-4 is the story of courage, innovation, and remembrance. It is the story of a Navy that, even in its earliest experiments with undersea warfare, showed that it would go to extraordinary lengths to honor those who dared to take the risks of the deep.
Patrol Reports 
Leave a comment